Most Valuable Rare Antique Fishing Lures: A Collector’s Guide

Fishing lures have been an essential part of the angler’s toolkit for centuries, helping to attract and catch fish more effectively.

Antique fishing lures have become highly sought-after collectibles with a rich and diverse history, often fetching impressive sums at auctions and private sales. In particular, rare and unique lures showcasing the evolution of fishing tackle design can be worth significant money.

The most valuable antique fishing lures were created during the early years of recreational fishing, often featuring intricate and innovative designs. Examples include the giant Copper Haskell Minnow, patented by Riley Haskell in 1859 and considered the most expensive lure in the world, selling for over $100,000 at auction in 2003. Other highly prized lures, such as the 1905 Wiggletail Smith Minnow and the Hardy Interchangeable Casting Minnow Box, showcase the creativity and craftsmanship of their time (Texas Antique Mall).

Collecting antique fishing lures offers a unique insight into the sport’s history and the evolution of fishing tackle technology. These valuable and rare lures serve as mementos of days gone by and have proven to be a worthy investment for many collectors.

Most Sought-After Fishing Lure Brands

A few brands stand out for their collectability and value regarding antique fishing lures. Among these treasured brands are Heddon, Shakespeare, Creek Chub, Pardee, and Pflueger.

Heddon is perhaps the most famous of all antique fishing lure brands. Founded by James Heddon in the late 1800s, their lures are highly sought after for their quality craftsmanship and innovative designs, like the 1897 hand-carved lure that is considered one of the rarest in existence today (Bassmaster).

Shakespeare was an early entrant into the fishing lure market and produced many popular baits during the early days of recreational fishing. The brand is known for its first-class materials and excellent construction, making its antique lures desirable to collectors.

Creek Chub is another iconic brand in the world of antique fishing lures. In the early 1900s, Creek Chub produced many lures, including the Silver Creek Floating Pikaroon and the Creek Chub Wagtail Special (TX Antique Mall).

Pardee lures have a rich history, connecting to the famous fishing lure makers Pflueger and the Twin Lakes area of Ohio. These finely crafted lures are highly sought after for their rarity and unique designs.

Pflueger is a renowned fishing tackle company that makes a variety of celebrated antique fishing lures. Collectors appreciate Pflueger’s creations for their innovative designs and quality workmanship.

These five brands are among the most cherished and valuable within the antique fishing lure-collecting community. Their innovative designs, quality craftsmanship, and unique features make them highly sought after by collectors and enthusiasts alike.

Top 10 Most Valuable Fishing Lures

Collectors prize antique fishing lures for their rarity and historical significance. The following is a list of the top 10 most valuable rare antique fishing lures, arranged from the most valuable to the least:

1. Haskell Minnow – This one-of-a-kind lure, created in the mid-1800s, is valued at over $100,000 and is characterized by a unique telescoping propeller and detailed hand-painting.
2. Giant Copper Haskell Giant Minnow – A bigger version of the Haskell Minnow made of copper, this lure boasts intricate craftsmanship and is highly sought-after among collectors.
3. Heddon Frog – A wooden, hand-painted frog imitation lure dating back to 1897, it can fetch thousands of dollars at auction, depending on its condition.
4. Charmer Minnow – Made in Springfield, Missouri, this early 1900s “barberpole” bait features a distinctive red and white striped pattern, making it an attractive item for collectors.
5. Immell Bait Company Floating Musky Chippewa Minnow – With a wooden body and red-painted details, this lure hails from Blair, Wisconsin, and is popular among collectors.
6. Growing Deer Minnow – With a metal lip and glass eye, this rare lure from the late 1800s can fetch a high price at auction due to its rarity and delicate crafting.
7. Shakespeare New Albany Bait – A beautiful example of the early 1900s lure design, these baits often include unique features such as pressed metal gills and belly markings, making them desirable collector’s items.
8. Miller’s Reversible Minnow – Featuring a unique double-ended design, this early 1900s lure stands out among collectors and can command a high price at auction.
9. Krantz & Smith Chautaugua Minnow – Known for its intricate metalwork and distinctive shape, this early 1900s lure is a prized addition to any antique fishing lure collection.
10. W.D. Chapman & Son Combination Minnow – This combination of a baitcasting reel and a minnow-shaped lure from the late 1800s is considered a rarity and can fetch a premium price at auction.

These highly collectible and valuable fishing lures offer a glimpse into the history of fishing and the artistry that went into creating early fishing gear. Collectors always look for these rare finds to add to their growing collections.

Factors Affecting Value

Several factors come into play when assessing the value of rare antique fishing lures. These factors can significantly impact the worth of a lure in the eyes of collectors and enthusiasts. This section will discuss the key aspects that determine the value of old fishing lures.

1. Condition: The lure’s condition is the most critical factor in determining its value. A lure with its original paint job and minimal wear are more likely to attract higher prices than a damaged or repainted one (Outdoor Canada).

2. Rarity: The rarity of a lure plays a significant role in its price. Rare items in excellent condition are more valuable than their common counterparts, even if the latter is in equally good condition. This is especially true for lures with limited production runs or those made by well-known manufacturers (Randy’s Antique Fishing Lures).

3. Age: The age of a lure can also impact its value. Given their historical significance and the dwindling number of surviving examples, older lures are generally more valuable than newer ones.

4. Provenance: The history or provenance of a lure might contribute to its worth. If a lure has a fascinating story, association with a famous fisherman, or documentation proving its origin, it can increase its value.

5. Demand: Lastly, the current market demand plays a role in determining the value of old fishing lures. A collector’s market for a specific type or brand can drive up prices, even for lures in less-than-perfect conditions.

How to Authenticate Rare Lures

Authenticating rare antique fishing lures involves examining various aspects of the lure to ensure its legitimacy, rarity, and value. While the process can be challenging, a thorough approach will help protect collectors and investors from accidentally purchasing counterfeit or heavily restored pieces.

Consider the following steps to authenticate rare lures:

1. Examine the Lure’s Construction: Inspect the lure’s body shape, paint patterns, and hardware. Comparing these features to known examples from specific manufacturers or periods can help identify the authenticity of the lure. Access resources such as books or online guides on antique fishing lures to reference when examining the lure.
2. Identify the Lure’s Materials: Genuine antique lures are usually constructed of wood, metal, or rubber. Analyze the materials to check for consistency and originality. Authentic materials, such as paint wear, wood discoloration, and metal patina, will typically show signs of aging.
3. Check for Markings and Branding: Many antique lures have maker’s marks, model numbers, or brand names stamped or embossed on their surface. Look for these markings and cross-reference the information with known records of manufacturers and production years. Be cautious of fake stamps and marks, as counterfeiters may attempt to age them artificially.
4. Assess the Lure’s Condition: Scrutinize the lure for signs of restoration, alteration, or excessive cleaning. While some degree of wear and tear is expected with age, excessive damage or inconsistencies in the finish may indicate a lack of authenticity.
5. Consult Experts: When in doubt, seek the advice of experienced collectors or specialists in antique fishing lures. They can provide valuable insights and help authenticate rare pieces. Consider attending collector’s events, joining online forums, or visiting specialized websites to connect with knowledgeable individuals.

By following these steps, collectors can increase their confidence in identifying and authenticating valuable rare antique fishing lures.

Care and Preservation

Proper care and preservation are crucial to maintaining the value and integrity of rare antique fishing lures. This section will discuss the essential steps for protecting these valuable collectibles.

Firstly, storing antique lures in a cool, dry environment, away from direct sunlight and temperature fluctuations, is crucial. UV rays and high temperatures can cause fading, warping, and other damage to the lures’ materials. A dedicated display case with UV-protective glass would be optimal, but storing them in clear plastic tackle boxes with compartments may also provide sufficient protection.

When handling your antique lures, always do so with clean hands or wear gloves to avoid transferring oils and dirt onto the lures. It is also essential to avoid exposing them to water, as moisture can lead to rust and deterioration. For example, keeping them in Hardy Interchangeable Casting Minnow Box or Hardy’s Silvered Minnow Box can help protect them.

Here are some tips for maintaining the condition of your antique fishing lures:

• Regularly dust the display case or storage container with a soft cloth to prevent the accumulation of debris.
• Use a magnifying glass to inspect your lures for damage, such as cracks or chips, and address any issues promptly.
• Consult an experienced collector or expert for guidance on proper care and handling techniques, mainly when dealing with rare or delicate lures.
• If your lures become dirty or tarnished, research the appropriate cleaning methods for the specific materials used in the lure. Avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive materials that could damage the surface.

Following these care tips and taking preventative measures will ensure the longevity and value of your antique fishing lure collection.

Final Word

In antique fishing lures, collectors seek out rare and valuable pieces that exemplify the craftsmanship and history behind these unique fishing tools. Some of the most valuable antique fishing lures include the 1905 Wiggletail Smith Minnow, Hardy Interchangeable Casting Minnow Box, and the Copper Haskell Minnow, considered the most expensive lure in the world.

These highly sought-after lures are significant for their rarity and historical importance and for the intricate designs and innovative features ahead of their time. Collectors can appreciate the workmanship and attention to detail that went into crafting these unique lures.

Although modern fishing lures have significantly evolved, studying and collecting antique lures, connect to the early days of recreational fishing and offer insight into the development of tackle technology over time. These lures remind us of the perseverance and creativity that fishermen used over a century ago and how their dedication laid the groundwork for the fishing industry we know today.

Notable antique fishing lure examples include:

• Wotta Frog Splatter
• Silver Creek Floating Pikaroon
• James Heddon Hand-carved Lure

Building a collection of valuable antique fishing lures can be both a rewarding and fascinating hobby, as it allows enthusiasts to explore the rich history of fishing while preserving these remarkable pieces of art and craftsmanship for future generations to appreciate.