Hey, fellow anglers! Welcome to my best ice fishing lures review.
I spent an entire week researching and testing 20 of the most popular ice fishing lures and combined my 10-plus years of ice fishing experience to come up with my top picks for ice fishing lures.
These ice fishing lures have proven to be effective for me over the years, and I am confident that will help you catch more fish more often.
You don’t have to read through every review on Amazon or go to your local tackle shop to get out on the water and start catching fish. Choose one of these ice fishing lures, and you’ll get a proven lure to help you catch more fish.
Ready to get on the ice and start catching fish?
Let’s go!
The best ice fishing lures are the jigs found within the Tungsten Ice Fishing Kit.
Best Ice Fishing Lures – Comparison Table
Best Ice Fishing Lures Reviewed
I have compiled a list of the best ice fishing lures for you to choose from. These ice fishing lures will help you catch more fish during those chilly winter months.
MUUNN Tungsten Ice Fishing Jig Kit
This ice fishing jig kit offers a variety of sizes and colors, making it perfect for any angler looking to up their game in the ice fishing season.
Pros
- Wide variety of colors and sizes
- Durable tungsten construction
- Waterproof storage case
Cons
- Some hooks are barbless
- Smallest jigs may be too small for some situations
- Case could be deeper for larger jigs
Last weekend, I took my new MUUNN Tungsten Ice Fishing Jig Kit out on the frozen lake, and I must say, it performed exceptionally well. The assortment of colors and sizes allowed me to easily switch my tactics and target various fish species lurking beneath the ice.
The tungsten construction of the jigs is dense and sinks quickly, enabling me to get my lure right into the strike zone. Additionally, the glow-in-the-dark coating boasted excellent luminous effects, attracting fish even in the murkiest of waters.
However, I realized a few downsides while using this kit. Some of the hooks were barbless, which proved to be a problem in securing my catch. Also, the smallest jigs seemed almost too tiny for practical use in certain situations.
The waterproof storage case, while convenient and well-sealed, could benefit from being deeper to accommodate larger jigs. Despite these minor issues, the MUUNN Tungsten Ice Fishing Jig Kit considerably improved my ice fishing experience and I would recommend it to fellow anglers.
Lindy Perch Talker Ice Fishing Lure
I found this lure to be incredibly effective for attracting perch, walleye, trout, and whitefish.
Pros
- Great flash, sound, and water displacement features
- Dropper chain increases catch rate
- Available in multiple fish-catching color combinations
Cons
- May tangle at times
- Not consistently effective for all users
- Might not work well in all locations
When I first tried the Lindy Perch Talker Ice Fishing Lure, I was pleasantly surprised by its beads and disk which added flash, sound, and water displacement, effectively attracting fish from a distance. The dropper chain helped me catch more fish as it kept the hook separate from the lure to target fish in neutral or negative moods.
One thing that concerned me was that the lure sometimes tangled up and didn’t stay straight. Nonetheless, it worked well on perch and walleye in various locations. I appreciate that the lure is available in a variety of proven color combinations, increasing its versatility and effectiveness in different environments.
In conclusion, I would recommend the Lindy Perch Talker Ice Fishing Lure to any angler looking for a versatile and effective lure to target perch, walleye, trout, and whitefish. Despite some minor drawbacks, its pros far outweigh the cons, making it a great addition to any ice fishing tackle box.
THKFISH Ice Fishing Jigs Kit
I highly recommend the THKFISH Ice Fishing Jigs Kit for ice fishing enthusiasts who desire variety, quality, and affordability in their tackle setups.
Pros
- Wide variety of shapes and colors
- Durable and sharp hooks
- Comes with a convenient plastic storage box
Cons
- Not all jigs glow in the dark
- Paint may wear off over time
- Might be too small for some fish species
Having used the THKFISH Ice Fishing Jigs Kit recently, I truly felt impressed by the variety of jigs it offers. This kit contains jigs in different shapes and colors, making it easy to switch up my selection based on the target fish species and preferences. The kit is suitable for both freshwater and saltwater fishing and works well for species like walleyes, bluegills, panfish, perch, sunfish, pike, and crappies.
The jigs are made of premium lead material and feature high carbon steel hooks, which provide durability and excellent penetration. This means a higher hook-up rate, ultimately improving my chances of catching more fish. I found the accompanying plastic box to be convenient for storage, organization, and transport.
While some of the jigs have a glow-in-the-dark feature enabling me to attract fish from farther depths, not all the jigs have this capability. It is important to be aware of this when selecting jigs to use in low-light conditions. Additionally, there were instances where the paint on some jigs started to wear off after rigorous use, which may reduce their attractiveness to fish over time. Lastly, certain jigs in the kit might be too small for catching larger fish species.
Overall, the THKFISH Ice Fishing Jigs Kit offers an impressive variety and quality at an affordable price. With 50 jigs in the set, it’s perfect for any ice fishing enthusiast looking to diversify their tackle collection. Just be aware of the few drawbacks mentioned above and consider the types of fish you’re targeting.
Laxygo Ice Fishing Jigs
I highly recommend these Laxygo Ice Fishing Jigs for their vibrant colors, versatility, and effectiveness in catching various fish species.
Pros
- Comes in a pack of 4 with different colors and two silver spins
- Suitable for targeting bass, walleye, trout, panfish, and pike
- Effective in both winter and frozen fishing conditions
Cons
- Hook may bend after catching larger fish
- Might be smaller than expected for some users
- Limited to only 4 pieces in each pack
During my recent ice fishing trip, I found the Laxygo Ice Fishing Jigs to be very effective in attracting different types of fish, thanks to their colorful painted design with a glittery surface. The jigs were especially successful in hooking bluegills, crappies, panfish, walleyes, and pikes. The combination of metal lures with their two silver spins and sharp black high carbon treble hooks proved to be an excellent choice for this fishing adventure.
In terms of weight and length, each jig measures 2.09 inches and weighs 0.21 ounces, making them easy to handle and convenient for casting. The design is well-balanced, allowing the jig to produce a tantalizing movement in the water that entices fish to strike.
Though the Laxygo Ice Fishing Jigs performed well overall, I did experience some issues with the hooks bending while catching larger fish, particularly with a hefty northern pike. However, I was able to bend the hook back into shape and continue fishing without much trouble.
To sum up, the Laxygo Ice Fishing Jigs provide an engaging and successful fishing experience, with vibrant colors and an effective design for attracting various fish species. Despite some minor issues with hook durability, these jigs are an excellent addition to any ice fisherman’s arsenal.
Dovesun Ice Fishing Lures Kit – 58pcs
In my experience, this all-in-one kit from Dovesun is a must-have for ice fishing enthusiasts who want variety and reliability in their tackle box.
Pros
- Sharp, high-quality carbon steel hooks
- Attractive colors and realistic designs
- Good assortment of lures for different fishing needs
Cons
- Small size might not suit all anglers
- Lead head requires extra care and handwashing
- The plastic storage box could be sturdier
When I first got my hands on the Dovesun ice fishing lure kit, I was immediately impressed with the selection available—58 pieces in total when including the soft lures. It covered every shape and size I needed for targeting various fish species, making it perfect for any ice fishing conditions.
Each lure in the kit features a high-quality carbon steel hook that I found to be strong and sharp. On a recent expedition, they provided great penetration and significantly improved my catch rate. Additionally, the attractive colors and realistic raised-fin attachments caught the fish’s attention throughout the day—an essential feature when fishing in cold, icy waters.
The size of the lures, while perfect for targeting smaller species like panfish, may not be suitable for those seeking more massive fish. I also noticed the lead head required extra care, and I had to remember to wash my hands after using them. Lastly, although the plastic storage box helped keep my lures organized, it could be more durable as it felt a bit flimsy.
Despite these minor flaws, the Dovesun ice fishing lures kit delivered a satisfying fishing experience for me. The assortment of shapes, colors, and sizes offered something for every ice angler. With proper care and attention to safety, this kit can become an essential component in any ice fisherman’s tackle box.
BASSDASH Ice Fishing Lures with Glide Tail Wings
These BASSDASH ice fishing lures are a must-have for any angler targeting bass, perch, walleye, and pike in winter conditions.
Pros
- Quality material and construction
- Luminous in the dark
- Versatile use for multiple freshwater gamefish
Cons
- Size variety could be improved
- Rear hook catches ice occasionally
- Glide action on drop might be inconsistent
While ice fishing this past weekend, I tried out the BASSDASH Ice Fishing Lures for the first time. I was immediately impressed by the quality of the materials and construction of these lures. The lead bodies provide a fast drop, and the ultra-sharp high carbon hooks enhance hook-up ratios. Additionally, the luminous paint and solid bright coating make these lures vibrant underwater and easy for fish to see, even in the dark.
As I jigged these lures, the glide tail wings and weighted body created a darting action that attracted the attention of various fish species, such as bass, perch, walleye, and pike. This versatility made me feel like I could use these lures in multiple fishing scenarios, not just on the ice.
However, there were a few minor downsides to the BASSDASH ice fishing lures. I noticed that the rear hook sometimes caught ice on the side of the hole, which was a bit inconvenient. Also, the glide action on the drop could be inconsistent at times. Additionally, I wished they offered a smaller size variety to target other species.
Overall, the BASSDASH Ice Fishing Lures are a solid addition to any angler’s winter fishing arsenal. Despite a few minor drawbacks, their quality construction, luminous design, and versatility make them a worthy investment for those looking to catch multiple freshwater gamefish through the ice.
Sougayilang Ice Fishing Lures
I highly recommend these lures for their lifelike design, good performance, and affordability.
Pros
- Lifelike artificial bait
- New design with hooks on head and tail
- Durable and solid construction
Cons
- Tails may break if handled roughly
- Finish could be improved slightly
- Uncertainty about bottom bouncing durability
I recently used the Sougayilang Ice Fishing Lures and was impressed by how lifelike they look underwater. The vibrant colors and intricate design certainly attracted the fish, and I caught bass, pike, and walleye with ease. With hooks on both the head and tail, these lures made it difficult for the fish to escape, increasing my success rate.
The lures are made of lead, which adds a solid feel to them. This also means they have a longer service life and can withstand regular use. However, I noticed that the finish could be slightly improved, and I’m unsure about how well the lures would hold up during bottom bouncing.
Though these lures are a great deal for the price, I found that the tails could break if not handled with care. Nevertheless, I think the Sougayilang Ice Fishing Lures are an excellent option for anyone looking for affordable and effective ice fishing lures. They may not be perfect, but their performance and lifelike design make them a valuable addition to any angler’s tackle box.
XBLACK Ice Fishing Jigs Kit
The XBLACK Ice Fishing Jigs Kit is a must-have for beginners and seasoned ice fishing enthusiasts alike.
Pros
- Wide variety of shapes and colors
- Sharp and durable high-carbon steel hooks
- Glowing in the dark for added attractiveness
Cons
- Some might find the plastic box flimsy
- Paint may chip off over time
- Limited sizes in the kit
I recently took the XBLACK Ice Fishing Jigs Kit out on the ice, and I have got to say, I was impressed. With 10 different shapes and various colors available for each shape, the bait selection makes it suitable for ice fishing no matter what you’re targeting – be it panfish, perch, or walleye.
One thing I noticed right away was the quality of the hooks. Made from high-carbon steel, these hooks were not only sharp but also durable, making it easy to catch fish without worrying about the hook bending or losing its sharpness.
While the jigs themselves are well-crafted, the plastic box they come in could be sturdier. I didn’t have any issues during my fishing trip, but I imagine it might not hold up well over time. Also, some paint on a few jigs chipped off after usage, which is worth considering when looking at durability.
The most appealing part of these jigs, in my opinion, is their ability to glow in the dark. If you’re ice fishing in darker conditions or murky waters, these jigs’ glowing feature increases their visibility, making them even more enticing to fish.
Overall, the XBLACK Ice Fishing Jigs Kit is a great addition to my fishing arsenal for when I’m ice fishing. It offers a broad range of options, and the quality of the jigs themselves is impressive.
QualyQualy Fishing Soft Lures
The QualyQualy Fishing Soft Lures are a must-have for ice fishing enthusiasts who desire realistic, glow-in-the-dark bait for increased catch rates.
Pros
- Lifelike soft lure design
- Ideal for various species
- Durable construction
Cons
- May tear after a few catches
- Smaller than expected
- Possibly inconsistent quantity
I tried the QualyQualy Fishing Soft Lures during my last ice fishing trip, and I was truly impressed by their realistic design. The glow-in-the-dark feature was especially helpful during early night fishing, attracting curious fish and increasing my catch rates. These lures work well for various species, such as bass, crappie, and walleye.
The solid construction of these lures ensured that they did not disintegrate even after catching several fish. However, I noticed that they could tear after a few catches, which may require more frequent replacements. Initially, I thought the lures were smaller than I expected, but their size proved effective for the species I was targeting.
One issue I encountered with these lures was that the number of pieces in the package seemed inconsistent. I expected 54 pieces, but I received only 30. Despite this, I found that these glow-in-the-dark soft lures were versatile and highly effective in attracting fish during my ice fishing adventures.
In conclusion, the QualyQualy Fishing Soft Lures are a great addition to any angler’s tackle box, especially for ice fishing enthusiasts. Although they may be slightly smaller and less durable than expected, their lifelike design and glow-in-the-dark feature make them worth trying.
Buying Guide For Ice Fishing Lures
When it comes to selecting the best ice fishing lures, there are a few important factors that I consider to ensure a successful ice fishing experience. In this buying guide, I want to highlight some key elements to look for when choosing ice fishing lures.
Size and Weight
The size and weight of the lure play a significant role in its effectiveness. Smaller lures are suitable for targeting smaller fish species, while larger lures are designed for bigger fish. I always keep a variety of sizes and weights in my tackle box to accommodate the type of fish I’m targeting.
Shape and Color
Since visibility is often limited in icy waters, opt for lures that are brightly colored or have a reflective surface. Lures shaped like fish or other prey can help attract the attention of target fish species. I tend to choose lures with a combination of attractive colors and realistic shapes.
Action and Movement
A good ice fishing lure should have a convincing action and movement, imitating the swimming motion of prey in the water. Ensure that the lure you pick has a lifelike action to attract the fish’s attention.
Durability
Ice fishing conditions can be harsh, and your lures should withstand the cold temperatures and potential impacts with the ice. I prefer buying lures made from durable materials like metal or hard plastic to achieve long-lasting performance.
By considering these factors and tailoring your selection according to the specific species you are targeting, you’ll be well on your way to a successful ice fishing adventure. Good luck!
Common Questions Related to Ice Fishing
What are the top lures for walleye ice fishing?
In my opinion, the top lures for walleye ice fishing are jigging spoons, swimbaits, and lipless crankbaits. Jigging spoons like the VMC Rattle Spoon and Northland Buck-Shot Flutter Spoon work great for attracting walleye with their erratic and fluttering actions. Swimbaits such as the Lunkerhunt Straight Up Jig have a realistic appearance that entices walleye to bite. Lipless crankbaits, like the Rapala Jigging Rap, move in a wandering manner, luring walleye to chase and strike.
Which new lures are best for perch?
The new lures I find most effective for perch include tungsten jigs, panfish-specific plastics, and small spoons. Tungsten jigs like the Clam Pro Tackle Drop Tg offer a smaller profile, making them ideal for finicky perch. For Panfish species, plastics, such as the Eurotackle Z-Viber, have a lightweight and compact design that mimics prey species like minnows or insects. Small spoons, like the Custom Jigs & Spins Demon Jigging Spoon, provide a fluttering action irresistible to perch.
What are the best spoons for ice fishing?
Based on my experience, the best spoons for ice fishing are the Northland Buck-Shot Flutter Spoon, VMC Rattle Spoon, and Lindy Rattl’n Flyer Spoon. These spoons offer a combination of fluttering action, rattling sound, and light reflection that can entice a variety of fish species. Their sizes and colors can be adjusted based on the target species and fishing conditions.
Which ice fishing hooks are the most effective?
I’ve found that effective ice fishing hooks include live-bait hooks, treble hooks, and finesse hooks. Live-bait hooks, such as the Gamakatsu Octopus Hook, work well when paired with minnows or other live bait. Treble hooks, like the Mustad UltraPoint KVD Triple Grip, offer superior hooking capabilities for artificial lures. Finesse hooks, like the VMC Finesse Neko Hook, are perfect for slow presentations and light-biting fish.
Are Rapala lures recommended for ice fishing?
Yes, I recommend Rapala lures for ice fishing because they’re highly effective and come in various options suitable for different species and conditions. For example, the Rapala Jigging Rap and Slab Rap are popular choices for walleye and perch, while the Rapala Snap Rap provides an excellent option when targeting other predatory fish like pike and lake trout. Rapala lures are well-built and offer lifelike presentations that can help increase success on the ice.
